1940

1940

Wonderful, Murderous Continent

World War II erupted just as my Hungarian family was reaching the pinnacle of its social status. World War II erupted just as my Hungarian family was reaching the pinnacle of its social status. World War II erupted just as my Hungarian family was reaching the pinnacle of its social status.
How do I know? Three clues... How do I know? Three clues... How do I know? Three clues...
FIRST

My grandfather, Pista, bought a fancy new Nettar Anastigmat. This German camera cost the equivalent of one-half of a Marcali teacher’s monthly salary (100 pengő), and was a luxury for a farmer. Pista proudly documented his family and the thriving family farm.

The Nettar Anastigmat camera that belonged to Pista Fábos Nettar Anastigmat Nettar Anastigmat Nettar Anastigmat
camera showing images emerging from its body
The Fábos family threshing machine in a field in rural Hungary in 1940 A view of the Fábos vineyard in rural Hungary in 1940 A view of Fábos vineyard farm shack in 1940 Three young and barefoot farm girls posing for the camera on the Fábos farm in rural Hungary in 1940 Gyula with Ari and cousins standing thigh-deep in the shallow waters of Lake Balaton in 1940 Marcali women in folk costume in 1940 Marcali corner store in 1940 Pista picking apples with hired farmworkers in 1940 Hired farmworker with horse on Fábos family farm in 1940 Bishop visiting Marcali Hungary and addressing small crowd in 1940 Ari standing in religious procession in Marcali Hungary in 1940 Bishop anointing Ari in Marcali Hungary in 1940 Ari posing in her Communion dress in Marcali Hungary in 1940 Numerous farmworkers posing on Fábos farm
SECOND

Pista and Gizi bought a DKW! Also made in Germany and pitched to the increasingly prosperous middle class customer, the lovely cherry-colored car was paid for with the sale of eighteen meat calves, to Italians. It cost 3500 pengő—what a Marcali teacher would earn in a year and a half.

Advertisement for DKW car from a 1939 sales brochure
(DKW stands for "Dampf-Kraft-Wagen," or "steam-driven car.") (DKW stands for "Dampf-Kraft-Wagen," or "steam-driven car.") (DKW stands for “Dampf-Kraft-Wagen,” or “steam-driven car.”)
DKW car in rural Hungary in 1940

The family could now take trips to Héviz, the Balaton, and all around Marcali; there were only ten cars in Marcali at the time, and Pista proudly drove one of them.

The one negative was that Gyula got carsick in the backseat and always had to get out at some point during each trip and throw up. The one negative was that Gyula got carsick in the backseat and always had to get out at some point during each trip and throw up. The one negative was that Gyula got carsick in the back seat and always had to get out at some point during each trip and throw up.
THIRD

Pista and Gizi sent their children to boarding schools in Keszthely, the nearest “big” town—about 30 kilometers to the north.

Ari and Gyula in 1940
Not a bad drive in the family's new DKW. Not a bad drive in the family's new DKW. Not a bad drive in the family’s new DKW.
Gyula helping with the hay harvest in 1941
Gyula helping with the hay harvest in 1941

By sending their daughter to a convent school and their son to a Catholic gimnázium (what they call high schools in Hungary), Pista and Gizi were imitating Hungary’s aristocracy, and clearly differentiating themselves from the other peasants in Marcali. Boarding school meant status, pride, and a better education. Pista made a special trip to Kaposvár in the DKW to get Gyula eyeglasses for school.

For Ari and Gyula, however, these schools didn't work out so well. Ari's school on Kossuth Lajos streen in downtown Keszthely was more like a prison. For Ari and Gyula, however, these schools didn't work out so well. Ari's school on Kossuth Lajos streen in downtown Keszthely was more like a prison. For Ari and Gyula, however, these schools didn’t work out so well. Ari’s school on Kossuth Lajos street in downtown Keszthely was more like a prison.
Hungarian Catholic girls in uniform waiting in line to enter their school
Hungarian girls in school Hungarian teenage girls in beds at a boarding school

It was forbidden to look out the window. The girls were required to eat all their meals in silence. If they found a worm in their milk, they had to drink it anyway.

The nuns were notoriously mean. All letters were censored going in and out. And the girls were only allowed a short walk twice a week (during which talking was forbidden!), to the dead nuns’ graves in the cemetery. Once a week each student received a lollipop, for which they had to curtsy and say “thank you, dear nun, for the lollipop.”

ARI FÁBOS

“I was a very vivacious child until the age of 10. I had a big mouth and I was very active. Once I got into the boarding school in Keszthely, I changed dramatically. My family barely believed it – after 3 months I became quiet and reserved, and I stayed like that.”

Gyula tried to cheer Ari up, but she doesn’t remember much family support. Their mother, Gizi, told Ari she was “selling vinegar” because of her pained expression. And so, Ari became stoic and serious, resolving that she would, from this point on, never cry. (She has kept her resolve to this day.)

Hungarian school girl observing nun
Gyula's school was just down the street but the two best friends rarely saw each other. Quite devastating, really. Gyula's school was just down the street but the two best friends rarely saw each other. Quite devastating, really. Gyula’s school was just down the street but the two best friends rarely saw each other. Quite devastating, really.
Keszthely Catholic Church

Gyula hated the smelly washcloth passed around to each boy after meals (they ate at their desks; the rag was used to clean the desktops, and the smell lingered on his fingers). He also disdained the doctors’ and lawyers’ kids, who labeled him a country hick and pelted him with snowballs. He was an unhappy outsider in this oppressive Catholic school.

From Ari and Gyula’s point of view, their parents’ decision to send them to boarding schools to raise the family’s status was not working out as blissfully as planned.

ANDhere’s another decision that didn’t work out quite as planned: when the Hungarian government decided to collaborate with Germany to regain the lands it wanted so badly—another decision based on pride and status—it seemed like a smart move at the time. But the price of territory was a deeper relationship with Hitler.

This relationship only intensified when Hitler gave Hungary yet another chunk of territory, this time in Northern Transylvania, in September 1940. Northern Transylvania! The territory of so many proud Hungarian princes! The center of “true Hungarianness” (for some) and the bedrock of Hungarian nationalism!

Animated map illustration showing the Second Vienna Award and the return of part of Transylvania 36 Getting this part of Greater Hungary back was a big deal. Getting this part of Greater Hungary back was a big deal. Getting this part of Greater Hungary back was a big deal.

Once again Horthy proudly led the Hungarian Army—with much pomp and circumstance—through Northern Transylvanian cities like Nagyvárad, which had belonged to Romania since 1918.

Horthy as Prince Árpád. Horthy as Prince Árpád. Horthy as Prince Arpad.
My grandfather, Pista, was a part of this brigade, driving an officer in a motorcycle sidecar. My grandfather, Pista, was a part of this brigade, driving an officer in a motorcycle sidecar. My grandfather, Pista, was a part of this brigade, driving an officer in a motorcycle sidecar.
Pista (on the far left) Pista (on the far left) Pista (on the far left)
Pista participating in the Hungarian re-occupation of Transylvania
I imagine him filled with Magyar pride... I imagine him filled with Magyar pride... I imagine him filled with Magyar pride...
Pista participating in the Hungarian re-occupation of Transylvania
Horthy honoring returning soldiers during the Hungarian re-occupation of Transylvania

HORTHY
was a national hero. Hungarians living in this chunk of land were jubilant. However, many of their Romanian neighbors (nowhere to be seen) were horrified, and had every reason to be: the Hungarian Army intimidated and in some cases massacred Romanian people. This was in retaliation for the terrible treatment the Romanian government had given Hungarians since 1918.

Hungarian troops hanging a large poster of Miklós Horthy in Nagydemeter Romania in 1940

It took the Hungarian troops eight days to re-occupy Northern Transylvania.

This award of land, referred to as the “Second Vienna Award,” carried other stipulations, too. Hungarian politicians were now obliged to...

LEGALIZEthe “Volksbund,” the National Socialist organization affiliated with the German minority in Hungary.
CONCEDEgovernment power to the Hungarian Arrow Cross — they were already the strongest opposition party in Hungary.
GIVEeconomic concessions to Germany — making the Hungarian economy wholly dependent on the Third Reich.
BEGINpreparations for the Third Anti-Jewish Law, which would prohibit intermarriage and penalize sexual intercourse between Jews and non-Jews. This law would pass in less than a year.
JOINthe Tripartite Pact between Germany, Italy, and Japan.
volksbund pin

BYSeptember, 1940, Germany had already invaded Denmark, Norway, France, Holland, Belgium, Luxembourg, and half of Poland. The Soviet Union had already invaded Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia, part of Romania, and the other half of Poland. Eastern Europe was being carved up into German and Soviet spheres of occupation (with Germany getting the bulk).

It appeared at first that the war would bypass Hungary.

But after reluctantly joining the Tripartite Pact on November 20, 1940, Hungary (though not officially at war) was an official German ally.

Large Nazi banners draped on the Industrial Hall of Budapest’s International Fair in 1941

1941

SOwhen Germany announced it wanted to pass through Hungary and invade Yugoslavia in March, 1941—just after Hungary signed a "Permanent Peace And Eternal Friendship" treaty with Yugoslavia—some Hungarian officials were quite torn.

Prime Minister Pál Teleki was so torn (did the word "permanent" mean nothing?) that he wrote a suicide note... Prime Minister Pál Teleki was so torn (did the word "permanent" mean nothing?) that he wrote a suicide note... Prime Minister Pál Teleki was so torn (did the word “permanent” mean nothing?) that he wrote a suicide note...
Prime Minister Pál Teleki

“...THE YUGOSLAV NATION

WAS OUR FRIEND...

BUT NOW,

OUT OF COWARDICE

WE HAVE ALLIED OURSELVES

WITH SCOUNDRELS...”

- PÁL TELEKI

...and shot himself. ...and shot himself. …and shot himself.

Horthy, who favored the invasion, appointed a new prime minister in Teleki’s place, and the tanks rolled on through.

The Hungarian government asked Hungarians to wave in support of the passing German troops. Pista and Gizi sent their children out instead. The siblings remember thousands of vehicles passing by their house as they rumbled south toward the Yugoslav border.

Although it wasn’t clear at the time, this was Hungary’s entry into World War II. This was the moment that would lead to dramatic changes all across Hungary, and certainly change the happy trajectory of my family’s social ascension.

German tank passing through Marcali
Here is a photo taken by my grandfather, Pista, with his new camera. There had only been ten cars in Marcali before 1941, and suddenly... thousands of cars and trucks, not to mention tanks and other machinery of war! Here is a photo taken by my grandfather, Pista, with his new camera. There had only been ten cars in Marcali before 1941, and suddenly... thousands of cars and trucks, not to mention tanks and other machinery of war! Here is a photo taken by my grandfather, Pista, with his new camera. There had only been ten cars in Marcali before 1941, and suddenly... thousands of cars and trucks, not to mention tanks and other machinery of war!

On April 11, 1941, 80,000 Hungarian troops crossed the Yugoslav border in support of the German-led Axis invasion of Yugoslavia that had commenced five days earlier.

POORYugoslavia, the Germans bombed them through and through. For Hungary’s compliance, Hitler gave a final territorial gift: two pieces of Yugoslavia that had belonged to pre-Trianon Hungary:

Animated map illustration showing the return of two pieces of Yugoslavia

Greater Hungary was on a path toward resurrection. Horthy and his succession of prime ministers were winning back Hungary’s land and pride. But at what cost?

As it turned out, Hitler's new European order didn't have a place for Hungary's mythical historic kingdom and its 1000-year-old borders... and the rumped state became the chumped state. As it turned out, Hitler's new European order didn't have a place for Hungary's mythical historic kingdom and its 1000-year-old borders... and the rumped state became the chumped state. As it turned out, Hitler’s new European order didn’t have a place for Hungary’s mythical historic kingdom and its 1000-year-old borders... and the rumped state became the chumped state.

After Hitler invaded the Soviet Union on June 22, 1941, Hungary would soon be asked to follow. In a shocking show of strength, Germany bombed Kiev.

Kiev bombed to bits in 1941

“WE HAVE ONLY

TO KICK IN THE DOOR

AND THE WHOLE

ROTTEN STRUCTURE

WILL COME CRASHING DOWN!”

- ADOLF HITLER

Kiev, Bombed to bits
An intimidating Hungarian soldier leather boots and trench coat straddling a stone wall in 1941

THEinvasion of the Soviet Union further radicalized Hitler’s Nazi regime, which began to systematically murder millions of Jews and Roma (often referred to as Gypsies), and anyone else they deemed worthless, to reconfigure Europe into a “racially pure” Aryan Empire. The complicity of many Hungarians in these horrendous crimes was astonishing.

Some of the earliest atrocities of World War II occurred in territories just reclaimed by Hungary: In August 1941, 16,000 “undocumented” Jews living in Hungary were deported to Kamenets-Podolski, Ukraine and murdered alongside 7,600 Ukranian Jews in just two days; in January 1942, Hungarian troops murdered thousands of Jews and Serbs in the recently-returned territory of Délvidék.

Hungarian anti-Semitism, and the idea of a racially pure Greater Hungary popularized by Gömbös in the 1920s, only increased during the war.

Groups of Hungarian soldiers in front of empty railway cars in 1941 Hungarian woman in fur coat flanked by anti-Semitic propaganda

In August 1941 Hungary passed its Third Anti-Jewish Law, which prohibited sexual encounters between Christians and Jews.

Hungary’s government also conducted a formal census in 1941 to identify all Hungarians by nationality. This meant that families who had lived their entire lives in Hungary (but perhaps spoke German at home), had to decide if they were more German or more Hungarian ... Some members of a family wrote down “German,” while others wrote down “Hungarian.” This decision would have dire consequences in just a few years’ time...

Furthermore, every Hungarian citizen, including my family members and every person living in Marcali, had to file official papers proving they were not Jewish in order to retain their citizenship.

Here is the special document that my family members secured based on a compilation of birth, marriage, and death certificates going back to my great-great-great grandparents a century later. Here is the special document that my family members secured based on a compilation of birth, marriage, and death certificates going back to my great-great-great grandparents a century later. Here is the special document that my family members secured based on a compilation of birth, marriage, and death certificates going back to my great-great-great grandparents a century earlier.
What a document! What a document! What a document!
In 1944, it would mean the difference between life and death... In 1944, it would mean the difference between life and death... In 1944, it would mean the difference between life and death...
official papers proving they were not Jewish

1942

Hungarian soldiers in railway cars and civilians waving goodbye in 1942

NOWthat Hungary was committed to fight in Germany’s war, Horthy reluctantly mobilized 277,000 men to the Eastern Front in July 1942. Included were about 37,000 Jewish men forced into labor battalions.

Hungarian Jewish men in Munkaszolgálat Hungarian Jewish men forced to march in the Munkaszolgálat
Soldiers marching on the Eastern Front

The mobilization was so badly calculated that soldiers had to walk 600 km to the front, which was along the Don River north of Stalingrad.

Arriving already exhausted, the Hungarians found obsolete anti-tank guns and pathetic amounts of ammunition. The high command had once again not prepared them for modern warfare, and the Germans naturally saved the best equipment for themselves. It felt like a repeat, in many ways, of what the Austro-Hungarian soldiers experienced during World War I.

Soldiers marching on the Eastern Front

1943

Winter on the Eastern Front in 1942

The winter came quickly; soldiers endured sub-zero conditions with inadequate clothing and the Germans ignored even the most minor requests. The Axis forces on the eastern front—which included Germans, Romanians, Italians, and Hungarians—had already collapsed by Christmas 1942.

When the Russians attacked on January 12, 1943, it was a disaster for the Hungarians (their worst defeat since Mohács in 1526), an epic loss for Germany, and a turning point in the war. Allying with Germany now seemed like a terrible idea.

bomber

MEANWHILE,the industrial-scale murder of Jews—using poison gas—was already underway. Unspeakable. Horror of horrors.

Meanwhile, the U.S. had just entered the war after Pearl Harbor, and roaring American bombers began to fly over Hungary. No bombs dropping yet ... but soon.

Meanwhile, Ari and Gyula were still at school, with Gyula’s “country hick” situation improving: in lieu of tuition Pista was now supplying both Keszthely schools with nice rich food from the family farm. However, it was impossible to think with bombers flying overhead.

Convoy of automobiles

Throughout Europe, 1943 brought more war misery and incomprehensible, nightmarish deaths. As novelist Amos Oz put it,

“EUROPE, THAT WONDERFUL,

MURDEROUS CONTINENT.”

- AMOS OZ

This murderousness was unbelievable ... on a scale so much worse than any war before.